Cuomo Case Great News for State Attorneys General

by Christopher Peterson

The Supreme Court has issued an opinion striking down the federal banking regulatory preemption of state fair lending enforcement lawsuits. The Court confronted whether ambiguity in the National Bank Act left the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency free to preempt state fair lending litigation originally brought by former New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer. In applying the administrative deference standard of Chevron U. S. A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., the Court explained:

[T]he presence of some uncertainty does not expand Chevron deference to cover virtually any interpretation of the National Bank Act. We can discern the outer limits of the term “visitorial powers” even through the clouded lens of history. They do not include, as the Comptroller’s expansive regulation would provide, ordinary enforcement of the law. Evidence from the time of the statute’s enactment, a long line of our own cases, and application of normal principles of construction to the National Bank Act make that clear.

Cuomo v. Clearing House Association, LLC.,  No. 08-453, slip. op. at 3 (U.S. June 29, 2009).

The decision reverses the trend in recent years, discussed here and here, of giving free reign to federal banking regulators to squelch the consumer protection efforts of state attorneys general. While the long-term impact of the decision is yet to be clear, the opinion is likely to embolden some state AGs in litigation against national banks and their subsidiaries over the subprime mortgage debacle.

Comments

[fix my credit]

Hey. Fantastic Blog you've got here. It's really refreshing to read some actual good content. I hit about 5 related sites before this one, and they were all garbage. Just thought I'd say thanks.

[consumer credit counsel]

Hey. Great blog you've got here. I definitely want to come and check out some more posts. I've bookmarked it to make sure I can! THanks!

[commercial loan modification]

love the blog. Lots and lots of useful information in just this post alone. I'm off now to read some more posts. Thanks.

[Keith Williams]

But wow, didnt we just bail out the banks? why now would we want to sue them back into bankrupcy???

[jennifer]

Attorney Find lists 70 categories of attorneys to help you find the type of attorney you are looking for, even if it's a lawyer for a more unusual niche. Listings include lawyers for personal injury, criminal defense and estate, as well as niches

like civil rights, securities arbitration and aviation law. All of these practice areas are divided into separate categories to help make your search for an attorney easier.
=================================
jennifer
Attorney