Latest HAMP report: Treasury program a failure

By Alan White

Treasury released its latest Home Affordable modification program (HAMP) numbers today. Despite their efforts to put a positive spin on it, the program is a failure.   A million homeowners have been lured into temporary payment plans with false promises of permanent loan restructuring.  After 11 months, only one in ten has had their mortgage permanently modified.  More disturbing is the fact that these one million homeowners in trial mods, i.e. short-term payment plans, were given a deadine of January 31 to convert to a permanent mod.  Treasury reports that about 33% of those who have been in trial payments for three months or more have missed payments.  The other two-thirds are making their payments.  That means that more than 500,000 homeowners are in trial modifications, making payments on time, but about to be kicked out of the program, presumably because of missing paperwork.

 

Mortgage servicers were permanently modifying around 100,000 loans a month before HAMP started.  HAMP’s highest monthly total yet was the 50,000 additional permanent modifications achieved in January 2010 (116,000 reported this month minus 66,000 reported last month).  Meanwhile, new foreclosure filings are adding 250,000 to 300,000 homes to the crisis every month. 

 

Rather than owning up to this dismal performance, Treasury continues to obfuscate the statistics. 

 

Treasury points out that there were also 76,000 modification offers pending at the end of January, in addition to a cumulative total of 116,000 done deals.  However, there were already 46,000 outstanding offers pending at the end of December.  Presumably, some of the 46,000 offers contributed to the 50,000 net new modifications for January.  In other words, you can’t really count this month’s modifications and the offers that will become next month’s mods in a single monthly tally.  New defaults and foreclosures are started monthly, foreclosure sales are conducted monthly (probably about 100,000), and a fair assessment of HAMP requires looking at monthly modifications, not cumulative 11-month totals. 

 

Bank of America continues lagging behind all its competitors, having concluded permanent modifications for just 3,200 out of more than a million eligible mortgages.  Other servicers have trial mod and conversion rates of ten times that.  BofA also happens to service more delinquent mortgages than any other company.  At this point the Administration needs to rethink its response to the foreclosure crisis.  The current plan is not working.

Comments

[dental care]

books are the gate of the imagination, where people can do things you always wanted and dream big, the knowledge gained is unmatched and are of a high cultural value!

[Jessica Rodriguez]

Well i think the effort of Obama to prevent a collapse of the Mortgage bussiness is have to be cheer, but the system do not help to much. I work with Hamp everyday and there always a mess especially in the Hamp Reporting portal they change things with updates and more updates and its is complicated when we have to calculate the front and back ratio and now the 0.5 % but if we see the other side we have to understand that this is a whole new program .We are learning by doing im so glad to have the opportunity to learn this and help a lot of homeowner to prevent foreclosure and keeping their homes, their dreams and their happiness

[Rblademan]

Some advice to those qualifying for a forebearance (3 month trial payment at slighly reduced payment). Do Not!!! I repeat Do Not!!! give your lender any money until you recieve something in writing that will permantly modify your loan. And when I say modify I don't mean tacking on the delinquent amount owed to the loan at a slightly reduced interest for a short-term. That is not a deal to the home owner. I am just one home owner, but I can stand-up to Wall Street by not giving my servicer anymore money until they negotiate with me "in good faith" or take my home. I am prepared for either result.

[scott]

Another reason govt should've either took over BofA or just let them burn......between reading they've only done 3200 permanent loan mods and the $3 billion bonus payout to Merrill why aren't they throwing some people in jail??? They're also one of the worst to deal with on short sales......let them burn!!

[home automation systems-71]

It is good to see posts that give truly quality information.I’m definitely going to look into it.Thanks for the encouraging words.I am really very impress with your article.Thanks a lot for sharing.Keep up the good works.

[Dave in Phoenix AZ]

The problem is Treasury/Obama have no power to do more other than the reporting to shame the banks and minor refinements.

The problem there is no enforcement provision. HAMP is not a law but forced upon banks that took TARP funds as part of the funding agreement. Now most have paid back the funds at a huge profit to TARP and the Treasury.

Congress needs to pass a HAMP law. HAMP is a great problem IF it was followed and instead of the usual 6-7+ of "3 month trials" servicers are finding or dreaming up all sorts of reasons to deny that are not part of the HAMP requirements.